Prayer
Saying amin aloud or quietly
What all agree on about saying amin after al-Fatihah, who said it aloud and who quietly, and the evidence of each.
After al-Fatihah the worshipper says amin, meaning "O Allah, answer". Scholars agree that it is said, and differ on whether, in the prayers recited aloud, the imam and those behind him say it aloud or quietly.
What everyone agrees on
- Saying amin after al-Fatihah is a sunnah for the imam, for those behind him and for one praying alone. The Prophet (peace be upon him) said: when the imam finishes the last ayah of al-Fatihah (al-Fatihah 1:7), say amin, for whoever's saying coincides with the saying of the angels is forgiven his past sins (Bukhari 782, Abu Dawud 935).
- He also said: when the imam says amin, say amin (Bukhari 780).
- In the prayers recited quietly, amin is said quietly.
- Saying it aloud or quietly does not affect the validity of the prayer in any of the four schools.
The views and who held them
- Aloud, in the prayers recited aloud: the view of al-Shafi'i and Ahmad and their schools. Al-Tirmidhi says more than one of the people of knowledge among the Companions, the Followers and those after them held that a man raises his voice with amin and does not hide it, and that it is the view of al-Shafi'i, Ahmad and Ishaq (Tirmidhi 248). Al-Bukhari named a chapter of his Sahih "the imam saying amin aloud", and mentions in it, without a chain, that Abdullah ibn al-Zubayr and those behind him said amin until the mosque echoed.
- Quietly: the view of Abu Hanifah and the Hanafi school, followed in Bangladesh, for the imam and those behind him. In the Maliki school those behind the imam say it quietly, and in its best-known view the imam does not say it in the prayers recited aloud.
The evidence of the first view
- Wa'il ibn Hujr reports that he heard the Prophet finish al-Fatihah and say amin, and he drew out his voice with it (Tirmidhi 248). Al-Tirmidhi called it hasan. In Abu Dawud's wording he raised his voice with it (Abu Dawud 932), and in another he said amin aloud (Abu Dawud 933); al-Albani graded the first sahih and the second hasan sahih. In another report Wa'il says: he said amin, and we heard it from him (Ibn Majah 855).
- "When the imam says amin, say amin" (Bukhari 780): those behind him know when he says it, which this view takes to mean he says it aloud.
- Al-Tirmidhi reports that al-Bukhari said Sufyan's report of Wa'il's hadith, with "drew out his voice", is more correct than Shu'bah's report with "lowered his voice", and that Abu Zur'ah said the same (Tirmidhi 248).
The evidence of the second view
- Shu'bah, one of the great imams of hadith, reported the same hadith of Wa'il with the words "and he lowered his voice with it", as al-Tirmidhi mentions (Tirmidhi 248). The Hanafis take Shu'bah's wording.
- Amin is a supplication, and Allah tells us to call on Him humbly and quietly (al-A'raf 7:55); so it is said like other supplications in the prayer.
- The hadith telling the followers to say amin when the imam finishes al-Fatihah (Bukhari 782) ties the followers' amin to the end of al-Fatihah, so they know its time without hearing the imam.
A closing note
By its chain, Sufyan's report of saying amin aloud is the stronger in the judgement of al-Bukhari and Abu Zur'ah, as al-Tirmidhi reports, and al-Tirmidhi says many of the Companions and Followers held it. The Hanafis follow Shu'bah's report and the principle that supplication is made quietly, and this has been the practice of a great part of the Muslim world for centuries.
Following any of these established views is valid, and it is no reason to blame anyone. In the mosque, follow your imam's practice. If you are unsure, ask a trusted local alim.
With the Tuhur app on your phone, links to this page open straight in the app. Download the app