Skip to content
Tuhur

Sign in, if you like

Your bookmarks, last place and reading settings will match the Tuhur app on your phone.

Sign in

About TuhurSources and Licences

Prayer

Raising the hands (raf' al-yadayn) beyond the opening takbir

What all agree on about raising the hands in salah, who raised them at ruku and who only at the start, and the evidence of each.

Raising the hands (raf' al-yadayn) means lifting them, palms facing the qiblah, to the shoulders or the ears with a takbir. Scholars differ on whether this is done again at ruku and on rising from it, or only at the opening takbir.

What everyone agrees on

  1. The hands are raised with the opening takbir (takbirat al-ihram) in every prayer. Ibn Umar reports that the Prophet (peace be upon him) raised his hands level with his shoulders when he began the prayer (Bukhari 735).
  2. They are not raised between the two sajdahs (Bukhari 735, Muslim 390).
  3. Raising or not raising the hands at ruku does not affect the validity of the prayer in any of the four schools; the question is which is the Sunnah.

The views and who held them

  1. Raising the hands at ruku and on rising from it as well: the view of al-Shafi'i and Ahmad and their schools, and one report from Malik. Al-Tirmidhi names among the Companions who held it Ibn Umar, Jabir ibn Abdullah, Abu Hurairah, Anas, Ibn Abbas and Abdullah ibn al-Zubayr; among the Followers al-Hasan al-Basri, Ata', Tawus, Mujahid, Nafi', Salim and Sa'id ibn Jubayr; and after them Malik, Ma'mar, al-Awza'i, Ibn Uyaynah, Abdullah ibn al-Mubarak, al-Shafi'i, Ahmad and Ishaq (Tirmidhi 256). Al-Bukhari wrote a separate book on it, Juz' Raf' al-Yadayn. Many also raise the hands on standing up after the first two rakats (Bukhari 739).
  2. Raising the hands only at the opening takbir: the view of Abu Hanifah and the Hanafi school, followed in Bangladesh, and the best-known view in the Maliki school, from Ibn al-Qasim's report of Malik. It is the practice of Ibn Mas'ud and his students in Kufa; al-Tirmidhi says it is the view of more than one of the people of knowledge among the Companions and the Followers, and of Sufyan al-Thawri and the people of Kufa.

The evidence of the first view

  1. Ibn Umar reports that the Prophet raised his hands level with his shoulders when he began the prayer, when he said the takbir for ruku, and when he rose from ruku (Bukhari 735, Muslim 390). Al-Tirmidhi called it hasan sahih (Tirmidhi 255), and lists more than a dozen Companions who report the same (Tirmidhi 256).
  2. Malik ibn al-Huwayrith reports the same from the Prophet (Bukhari 737).
  3. Abu Humayd al-Sa'idi described the Prophet's prayer, with raising the hands at ruku and on rising, in front of ten Companions, among them Abu Qatadah, and they said he was right (Abu Dawud 730, Tirmidhi 304). Al-Albani graded the Abu Dawud report sahih.
  4. Abdullah ibn al-Mubarak said the hadith of those who raise the hands is established, and that Ibn Mas'ud's hadith of raising them only the first time is not established (Tirmidhi 256).

The evidence of the second view

  1. Alqamah reports that Ibn Mas'ud said: shall I not pray for you the prayer of the Messenger of Allah? Then he prayed and raised his hands only once (Abu Dawud 748). Al-Tirmidhi also reports it and called it hasan, and al-Albani graded the Abu Dawud report sahih; Abu Dawud himself said it is shortened from a longer hadith and is not authentic in this wording.
  2. Ibn Mas'ud was among the Companions closest to the Prophet and prayed behind him for many years, and the Hanafis give his practice and that of his students great weight. Al-Tahawi gathered the reports on this from the Companions in Sharh Ma'ani al-Athar.
  3. A report from al-Bara' ibn Azib that the Prophet raised his hands at the start and "then did not repeat" is weak: Abu Dawud reports that Sufyan said the narrator Yazid ibn Abi Ziyad added those words later, in Kufa, and that other students of Yazid did not mention them (Abu Dawud 751).
  4. Some Hanafi scholars also cite the hadith "why do I see you raising your hands like the tails of restless horses? Be still in prayer" (Muslim 430). Others answer that another report of the same hadith shows it was about pointing with the hands at the salam (Muslim 431).

A closing note

By its chain, the hadith of raising the hands at ruku is the stronger: it is in Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim, and al-Tirmidhi lists many Companions who narrate it. Ibn Mas'ud's report was graded hasan by al-Tirmidhi and sahih by al-Albani, and questioned by Ibn al-Mubarak and Abu Dawud; it is the practice of Ibn Mas'ud's school in Kufa, from which the Hanafi school grew. Some scholars hold that the Prophet did both at different times.

Following any of these established views is valid, and it is no reason to blame anyone. If you are unsure, ask a trusted local alim.

With the Tuhur app on your phone, links to this page open straight in the app. Download the app